The Mind (part 1 of 2)

Mind and reason are an essential part of Islamic thought and legislation.  One could not exist without the other.  What exactly do we refer to when we talk about the mind? There are two kinds of reasoning by the mind that have been identified.

The first is intuitive reasoning that includes: the capacity to comprehend, make rational conclusions, form speech and behave sensibly.  The second kind of reasoning is acquired from our environment, such as the things we have been taught or become familiarized with.

I shall discuss intuitive reasoning for it is what God has granted to all, and it is what makes us accountable for our behavior.  One who does not possess a mind or has lost his mind cannot be fully responsible for what he does.

Often, a person will have a good mind, and then choose not to use it or restrain it from thinking logically when it comes to matters of religion and faith.  He will end up being one of the unfaithful and will be held accountable for his ignorance in religion.

"And it is not for any soul to believe, except by the leave of God, and He lays abomination on those who have no understanding." 

(Quran 6:125)

These two verses point out that one cannot possibly purify his heart unless he puts his mind to work, allowing faith and security into his heart.

The Quran refers to the mind in different ways depending on the nature of the task being dealt with:

1. The mind is able to understand and process speech.

"Do you (Muslims) expect that they (Jews) will be believers, while some of them used to listen to the revelation of God (Torah), then intentionally tamper with it, while they understood it and knew it was the Truth?" 

(Quran 12:2)

The reason the Quran was revealed in Arabic was so that the minds of the people upon whom it was descended would be able to grasp it and appreciate its meanings.

2.    The mind is able to project coherent and non-conflicting thoughts. 

"O people of earlier scripture! Why do you argue about Ibrahim, when the Torah and Injeel were not revealed until after him? Do you not have minds?"

( Quran 3:65)

Those who claim that Ibrahim was a Jew or a Christian are contradicting themselves, since both Judaism and Christianity came long after the time of Ibrahim.  The surah of al-Anaam (Chapter 6), verse 91, also refers to the Jews contradicting themselves:"And they did not attach the proper esteem to God when they said, ‘Allah has not revealed anything to any human.’  Say, ‘Who then sent down the Book which Moses brought as a light and as a guidance to people, which you divided into fragments, part of which you show to the people, and most of which you hide from them, and you were taught knowledge which neither you nor your fathers had possessed! Say, ‘It is God,’ then leave them to churn in their vain discourses."

The verse points that the Jews cannot claim to believe in the prophecy of Moses, and in the Torah, then go on to say that God did not reveal anything to any humans, because those are contradicting thoughts.

3.    The mind is able to understand proof and evidence of truth. 

"He has set for you an analogy from your lives: Have you, among that which your right hands possess, partners in what We have bestowed on you sharing with you equally, and you fear them as you fear each other? Thus we make clear the signs for people who understand." "Say, ‘If God had pleased, I would not have recited the Qur’an to you, nor would you have had any knowledge of it, indeed, I have already lived among you for a lifetime before it, do you not understand?" 

(Quran 2:44)

This verse is reprimanding the people, not for encouraging others to adhere to the way of God, for that is always a virtue.  The verse, however, is pointing out the contradiction of the people who are giving good advice but not taking it themselves.  In any case, how the giver of good advice behaves does not reduce the value of the advice, such as a smoker or an alcoholic warning his children against the harms of those behaviors.  It is far better than encouraging them to take on such harmful habits and better than not giving them any useful advice at all.  Still, it does not make much sense to recognize the value of behaving in a certain way, and encourage others to do so, while acting in an opposing manner.  For this reason, the good Prophet in the Surah of Hood (Chapter 11), verse 88 said,"He answered, ‘My people, can you not see? What if I am acting on clear evidence from my Lord? He Himself has given me good provision: I do not want to do what I am forbidding you to do, I only want to put things right as far as I can.  I cannot succeed without God’s help: I trust in Him, and always turn to Him."

Choose Your Language